THELIKEGAMES

Search
Generic filters

Top similar games like Pony Island

Pony Island: Where the Pixels Hide a Devilish Delight

Pony Island isn’t what it seems. This isn’t your typical, cutesy pony game. This is a suspense puzzle game disguised as something far more sinister. You find yourself trapped in a malfunctioning arcade machine, a twisted creation of the devil himself.

The game’s deceptive facade is just the beginning. As you delve deeper, you’ll discover a world of broken code and malevolent programming. The devil, a master of deception, delights in watching you struggle. He throws insults your way, taunting you with his twisted sense of humor.

But Pony Island isn’t just about solving puzzles. It’s about breaking free from the devil’s control. You’ll need to think outside the box, exploit the game’s flaws, and even manipulate the very code that binds you.

This indie gem is a testament to creative storytelling. It’s a game that challenges your assumptions, pushes your limits, and leaves you questioning the very nature of reality.

So, if you’re looking for a truly unique and unsettling gaming experience, dive into the depths of Pony Island. Just be prepared for a ride that’s as thrilling as it is terrifying.

Are you searching for games like Pony Island?

You’ve come to the right place! Our website is dedicated to helping gamers find the best games that are similar to their favorite titles. In this list, you will find games similar to Pony Island. The games are sorted by their release date, with the newer ones listed first.

HELLSEED: All Chapters

  • Atmospheric, Exploration, Horror, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Stealth, Survival Horror
66%

Steam score

2024

Release year

Profenix Studio SRLS

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Experience the terrifying HELLSEED, a psychological horror game lauded for its intense scares. Set in 1980s Italy, you investigate a doctor’s disappearance, uncovering a dark mystery through exploration, puzzle-solving, and terrifying encounters. Prepare for jump scares, intense gore, and a chilling atmosphere inspired by classic Italian horror. Will you survive?

Violent Horror Stories: anthology

  • Atmospheric, Dark, Exploration, Horror, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Simulation
90%

Steam score

2024

Release year

Trioskaz, BOBER BROS

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Dive into “Violent Horror Stories,” a chilling anthology where “pursuit” takes terrifying new forms. Each short, distinct game—from psychological horror to bizarre cartoon chaos—offers a unique take on escape and dread. Expect the unexpected in these twisted tales, each lasting 15-30 minutes of intense fear.

Baisu

  • Atmospheric, Detective, Dog, Horror, Psychological Horror, Realistic, Story Rich
86%

Steam score

2024

Release year

Tripleducks studio

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Unravel a chilling mystery in *Baisu*, a photorealistic horror game. Play Detective Kriest, aided by a loyal dog, as you explore a haunted artist’s secluded home. Solve puzzles hidden within eerie paintings, confront a malevolent force, and face multiple endings in this nerve-wracking bodycam adventure. Will you survive the haunting unknown?

Asleep – Ato 1

  • Dark, Horror, Point & Click, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Story Rich, Survival Horror
96%

Steam score

2024

Release year

Nuuvem Inc

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Lost in 90s Brazil, Ana Lúcia battles nightmares in *Asleep – Ato 1*. This 2D point-and-click horror blends pixel art with fluid animation, challenging players to solve puzzles and escape monsters using light and wit. Sanity is a resource; darkness breeds chaos. Explore two realities, uncover secrets, and survive Ana’s descent into madness.

Shipwrecked 64

  • 3D, Exploration, Horror, Platformer, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Strategy
96%

Steam score

2024

Release year

Cogware Games

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Shipwrecked 64: a lost ’90s game resurfaces! This puzzle-adventure, mysteriously released for only four days in 1997, is now playable. Its dark, surreal story blends reality and fiction, demanding community collaboration to unravel its secrets. Explore, solve puzzles, and uncover the truth behind Cogware Games’ cryptic creation. Dare to play?

Exiled

  • Dark, Horror, Mystery, Point & Click, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Survival Horror
94%

Steam score

2024

Release year

John Szymanski

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Exiled: A 45-minute puzzle thriller plunges you into a mysterious library where scholar Charlotte vanished. Decode an ancient language, using clues from an eldritch tome to unravel her disappearance and evade lurking horrors. Think *The Room* meets *Myst*, with chilling atmosphere and a voice-over by Tom Schalk. Solve the mystery before it’s too late!

Ad Infinitum

  • Atmospheric, First-Person, Gore, Horror, Psychological Horror, Survival, Survival Horror
82%

Steam score

2023

Release year

Nacon

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Trapped in a WWI nightmare, Ad Infinitum blends the horrors of trench warfare with a decaying family manor. Haunted by gruesome creatures born from your memories, you must unravel a family’s wartime secrets to break the cycle of suffering and escape the blurring line between dream and reality. Prepare for psychological horror and chilling puzzles.

Decarnation

  • 2D, Dark, Emotional, Horror, Puzzle, Story Rich, Surreal
90%

Steam score

2023

Release year

Shiro Unlimited, East2West Games(Greater China)

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Dive into Decarnation, a surreal horror adventure where cabaret dancer Gloria’s reality unravels. Inspired by Lynch and Kon, it blends dream and nightmare, challenging you with cryptic puzzles and chilling encounters. Akira Yamaoka’s haunting score amplifies the descent into madness. Can you unravel its many cult horror references?

Hello Neighbor 2

  • Action-Adventure, Atmospheric, Colorful, First-Person, Horror, Parkour, Puzzle
71%

Steam score

2022

Release year

tinyBuild

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Raven Brooks hides a sinister secret! In *Hello Neighbor 2*, play as investigative journalist Quentin, infiltrating homes and uncovering the truth behind Mr. Peterson’s chilling past. Explore a vast, open world teeming with AI-driven residents and solve a puzzle where nothing is as it seems. Unravel the mystery—if you dare.

The Death | Thần Trùng

  • Casual, First-Person, Funny, Horror, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Realistic
93%

Steam score

2022

Release year

DUT Studio

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Dive into the chilling mystery of *The Death | Thần Trùng*, a Vietnamese psychological horror adventure. As an ordinary young man in 2022 Hanoi, you’ll unravel a terrifying personal enigma through unsettling events and atmospheric exploration. Multiple endings and jump scares await – but can you handle the truth? Prepare for a truly creepy walking simulator experience.

MADiSON

  • Dark, First-Person, Horror, Psychological Horror, Puzzle, Survival, Survival Horror
87%

Steam score

2022

Release year

BLOODIOUS GAMES

Developer

Similars
Steam page
Trapped, bloody, and haunted by the demon MADiSON, you must complete a gruesome ritual. This first-person horror game blends disturbing gameplay, a compelling narrative, and terrifying visuals. Solve puzzles, develop photos, and escape—if you can.